Sunday, November 29, 2009

Second Peer Response

Emily, first off let me apologize, Blogspot has not been registering my posts whenever I have tried to post. A short time ago it allowed me to post my response to Jim's, I can only hope Blogspot will allow this response to post...

Emily, I really love your topic, I find it very interesting and I believe it is one to keep an eye on! Your sources appear to be very legitimate and each source contains loads of information. Keep an eye on your spelling and grammatical errors, possibly typing each post on some type of program such as word, pages or open office might limit those errors. I wonder if your responses could be a tad longer? Try to proportion your responses and notes in a way that shows complete thinking and truly reflects upon the article. I found the interview intriguing to read and commend you for being able to arrange that interview! As a whole, excellent idea, I see this building into a very resourceful blog.

Monday, November 23, 2009

Response: California Awards Grants for Research Projects in Nonembryonic Stem Cells. 7

I chose this article specifically because it was recommended that I look more into the politics of stem cell research, and also because this article compared multiple types of stem cells (something that was also recommended I look into.)

Reading a side by side comparison of hESCs to adult stem cells made my hopeful that there will be a way around using hESCs. My main opposition to hESCs was mentioned in this article. I'm uncomfortable with the fact that hESC research requires the destruction of human embryos. There's no way around this destruction during the research, so hopefully there will be a way around the research all together. However after reading this article, I would support hESC research if that was the most effective way to treat a specific disease, but only those certain diseases it was necessary for.

This article answered a lot of questions I've had about adult and embryonic stem cells. Adult stem cells don't have as much of a variety of what they can treat, while it's believed that hESCs can treat close to any disease. I had always thought that they had the same variety of treatment options, but this article proved me wrong.

One portion of the article that I found incredibly fascinating was the treatment of AIDS. If they are able to cure HIV/AIDS by replicating the bone marrow that seems to be resistant to the disease, that would be an incredible break through. A once incurable disease would be treatable and would change many people's lives. I look forward to following this information that I found and seeing if any where else is working on this area of research. This remarkable discovery was made in Berlin, Germany, where the patient was treated.

Notes: California Awards Grants for Research Projects in Nonembryonic Stem Cells. 7

$230 million in grants was recently awarded to California. The grants are to be used for pushing stem cell research further into developing therapies for a multitude of diseases (anything from cancer to AIDS).

In only four years the recipients of the grants are expected to have the research far enough along to be able to do human testing.

4 out of the 14 projects involve hESCs, and the others will use adult stem cell. However, adult stem cells are thought to "give rise to tumors" (Andrew Pollack, p. 1).

The grants shy away from the voter's original intent. In 2004 California approved a 10 year, 3 billion dollar effort to work around the restrictions of hESC research set by President George W. Bush. These new grants focus mainly on adult stem cells. This year President Obama's administration has lessened the severity of the restrictions.

hESC research is very controversial because the research of hESCs requires the destruction of human embryos (the main reason why I'm not yet a supporter.)

Voters say to "pursue the very best cell type for each disease." California voters that chose to support these past research votes, are not opposed to hESC research as long as they believe it will be helping more people in the long run. It doesn't make a difference to them which type of stem cell is being used as long as the disease is being treated in the best way possible.

The grants however, do not support the thoughts of many California voters. Instead the grants side with the view that adult stem cells are so close to a breakthrough that they will soon be as effective as hESCs, without the controversy.

hESCs grow easily and can form almost any type of tissue in the body. Researches hope to be able to use hESCs to create heart cells, brain cells, and any other kind of tissue. To avoid the hESCs from turning into tumors, the cells first have to be purified to the specific type of cell they're used to create before they are cultured.

Adult stem cells have a more limited range compared to hESCs as to how many different types of tissues they're able to create. On the plus side for adult stem cells, they've been researched much longer than hESCs and through bone marrow, they are already used in a variety of treatments.

One project being funded by the grant is taking cardiac cells from the heart and putting them into culture where they can grow into new heart cells. When they reach this point they will be put back into the heart where they will hopefully repair the damage done by a heart attack.

Another project is to use stem cells to treat type 1 diabetes. Projects using hESCs include treating strokes, Lou Gehrig's disease, and macular degeneration (and eye disease.)

One project will use pluripotent stem cells (which have many of the same qualities of hESCs) to treat a rare skin disease called epidermolysis bullosa.

A very exciting project will attempt to replicate one person's possible cure of their AIDS last year. The patient also had leukemia (cancer of the blood.) and received a bone marrow transplant. The bone marrow seemed to be resistant to HIV making the recipient of the bone marrow also resistant to HIV.

Thursday, November 19, 2009

Second Peer Blog Response

Your notes were very good, if a bit brief. The interview was really good (especially for an email interview, those can be difficult). You really seem to be learning a lot and you appear to be very open to different opinions.

Your responses are very well done. There were a few typos, but nothing major. (Make sure you spell response correctly!) I like how you came back to questions and points that you made in earlier posts and tied it all together. Everything came together very neatly. Obviously, this is a hard topic because of the vocabulary and the science involved. You seem to be coping with that quite well, but I think it would be beneficial if you explained some of the terms more and really got acquainted with the topic.

As I said, everything is really coming together. You seem very interested in this topic, and because of that the blog is interesting to read. I like how you drew politics in, I think that it would be interesting to expand on that so that you focus equally on the political, scientific and social aspects of stem cell research.

The writing for the interview was hard to read, as the others said, but apart from that the blog was very easy to read. Your layout is reasonably professional, which is nice. I think it would be good to have all of the fonts the same size. There was some variation in the text which was disconcerting. Your citation is beautiful.

Great job.

Second Peer Blog Response

As a general, you seem to be on track with your research but the following are some thoughts to consider:
You seem to know where to find strong, detailed and accurate information, yet your notes on this information are varied in quality. In some notes you are very considerate to detail and go into great depth about the topic; it feels as though one had read the article by the end of them. Whilst in other notes you come across as a little uninterested for you lack much detail. Just try to stay with the greater depth. Your responses tend to be a tad inconsistent as well. In some, you simply restate your notes wit some added detail (which should have been in the notes in the first place) while in others you go on only about your opinions on the matter at hand with out backing them up with facts from the notes. Try to combine your opinions with the facts to make your points more clear. As I have already said, you know where to look for your information. Your interview was detailed and thoughtful, and all your other resources are strong as well. Its nice that you make it so obvious what you are learning, if you have an interest in this filed, you are certainly well along the way to understanding it. So far, you have only reviewed several different types of stem cells, but can you compare them? You seem a little conflicted with your opinions on this issue, can you go into more depth about how each type of treatment effects this? Finally, your blog is well organized and easy to read, but a little dull on the edges, perhaps a brighter or fuller background color would make it more appealing. Also, the red text in your interview is challenging to read.

Second Peer Blog Response

The notes you took were very informative, but they weer also breif. The information given in the notes was all valid and good information, there just was not much of it. The only suggestion that I have is to provide more information in your notes.
Your responces were very well written and contained alot of information and thoughts. They all had a lot of depth and it was clear that much thought was put into them. Some insights that I gained from the responses was your opinion on certain topics, such as hESC's. I think that the responses would be stronger if you put more opinions in them.
It is very clear that your thoughts are developing throughout your blog posting. For example, you took notes on the man who used his own stemcells, and then the next set of notes was an interview. I thought that the interview was a great idea and provided some good information onj the topic. I believe that the author is learing all about stem cell research and stem cell expirements. You should explore more in the field of politics because I'm sure that there is plenty happining to try to changes laws and that sort of thing.
There is definite connections between the articles posted. I think that more background information would be helpful not only to the reader but to the author. You posted that you did not know alot about stem cell research and I think that more background information would help you.
There are no visual aids in any of your posts. The colors are easy to read, except for the red used in the interview. All of the citations are complete.
The titles are all correct and the blog posts are complete. There are not any extra entries in the blog.

Wednesday, November 18, 2009

Stem Cells are not All Equal: Response Ch.1 6

I found Stem Cell Research by Joseph Panno, Ph.D in the school's library. This book provided straight forward information as well as pictures and diagrams that helped me to understand a lot of the terminology in the articles I've been reading.


What I found most interesting was that embryonic stem cells have more plasticity that adult stem cells. This means that the cell can be manipulated without be destroyed. Using this book as my source of background information is going to be very helpful to me in the future.

The articles that I've been choosing to read are becoming more and more dense. What I mean by this is that the articles have a lot of terminology that I don't understand, at all. The book has already cleared up some of the lingering questions and confusion that I have when reading challenging articles.


Stem Cell Research reminds me of a text book for exactly what I'm learning about. This book gives me both history on the subject (where it originated, dates of first discoveries, etc.) as well as definitions and examples of how the definitions relate back to stem cells in real situation.

Stem Cells are not All Equal: Notes Ch.1 6

the plasticity of a cell depends on if the cell originated in the embryo or from an adult.
stem cells from embryos tend to have greater plasticity
stem cells from adult organisms have less

most of what we know about embryonic stem cells comes from mice.
rodent stem cells were tested on and manipulated throughout the 1990's

in vito stem cells are cells in a living organism
in vitro stem cells are cells in cell culture
it's important for in vetro cells to grow and divide. also important for a cell to maintain it's observable characteristics during it's time while it grows and divides.

glycocalyx- "molecular forest that covers the surface of all cells" (Panno, p. 1).

"The ultimate stem cell is the fertilized egg..." (Panno, p.5)

scientists demonstrated the plasticity of embryonic stem cells in the 1980s for the first time.

cardiomyocyte - cells that make the heart

keratinocyte - cells that make hair and nails

neuron - cells that make the brain, spinal cords and peripheral nervous system.

the plasticity of adult stem cells is less than that of embryonic stem cells


Thursday, November 12, 2009

Responce: Stem Cells, Growth and Developement article 5

I'm not an advocate for human embryonic stem cell research, or any kind of embryonic stem cell research. Personally I wouldn't be comfortable knowing that a potential person was used to build cells for me. However in order to fully understand my topic (stem cell reseach and developements) I need to understand every part and type of stem cell research and set aside my personal opinions. Seeing many types of stem cell developement helps to make me more knowledgeable of my subject. That is why I chose this particular article to read.

I found it interesting that they hadn't been able to collect any embryos as of September 2009. Are the new restrictions too difficult to weed through? Is the process to complex for donors to feel comfortable in donating embryos? It seems that in the other areas of stem cell research that I've learned about scientists seem to be making significant advances while in hESC research they are delayed with the challenge of making it past all the restrictions and prohibited specifics that have been set in place for hESC research.

The article itself seemed very political and that made it challenging for me to figure out what was actually affecting hESC research, and what was the political dispute as well as political terminology. In the future I would prefer to read about more of the science of the research, it appeals to me more than the political side. However, I need to keep the research I'm doing current, and the government continues to lift as well as create new restictions on stem cell research, so politics are going to have to be part of my research.

Notes: Stem Cells, Growth and Developement article 5

In March 2009 Obama lifted restrictions on embryonic stem cell research in the US.

This pleased many scientests and advocates of stem cell research as well as possible patients.


New guidelines say the the National Institutes of Health (NIH) can provide with funding for hESCs research coming from human embryos.


the only embryos used are from donators with excess eggs from in vetro fertilization. the donors have given consent and are fully aware that their embryos are being used for hESC research.


"full promise of stem cell research remains unknown, and it should not be overstated." is a quote from President Obama's notes on the research.


the cell registry for hESC research was still empty as of September 2009.


some scientists believe that the next major breakthrough will be to have permission to have human trials with the hESCs.


Thursday, November 5, 2009

Responce: Histostem 4

I was pleased that the article from CNN on the Histostem company supported an opinion I've had for a while. I think that using stem cells from the umbilical cord should be more widely practiced. Reading about how it has helped people that were suffering with leukemia restored my faith in the study of stem cells from the umbilical cord. Until now I have not been able to find current information about hematopic stem cells, I didn't even know the correct term for them.


This article has been enlightening to say the least. Histostem's projected annual profit has once again proved that stem cell research is a current and developing topic. If a company's worth can jump from 1.8 billion to 3.5 billion in the course of only 3 years, it has to be something important. The Stem Cell Therapy International company from which Histostem developed, would be something I would like to look into. In the future months I would like to research the progress that they have made to ensure that the topic isn't going to fade quickly.

Notes: Histostem 4

Histostem Ltd. in South Korea is a subsidary company from Stem Cell Therapy International, inc.

hematopic stem cells are being used to treat patients with lukemia.

this is being practiced in Hong Kong, China

Histostem is the first Korean company to provide this type of hematopic stem cells, they're stem cells from the umbilical cord.

Histostem is expecting a 25% annual growth rate for their company, making them a large developing power. $1.8 billion in 2009 to an estimated $3.5 billion by 2012.

Histostem has treated 500 patients to date through this type of hematopic treatment.

Their designs and discoveries have, so far, earned them 6 patents and they currently have 5 more pending.

They are one of the few companies out there that's able to profit from their new technology.