Sunday, February 28, 2010
Interview Questions for Prof. Slavin
Thursday, February 25, 2010
Response: Stem Cell Approvals 15
Notes: Stem Cell Approvals 15
Friday, February 19, 2010
Parent comment
BLOG COMMENT
MY NAME as author of the blog: Emily Whitaker
TITLE OF MY BLOG: New and Developing Stem Cell Research
NAME OF PERSON WITH WHOM I SHARED MY BLOG: Colleen Whitaker
RELATIONSHIP OF PERSON TO ME: Mom
DATE I SHARED MY BLOG: February 18, 2010
COMMENTS FROM RELATIVE WHO LISTENED TO MY EXPLANATION AND READ MY BLOG:
After reading the blog entry in it’s entirety, I can say how interesting it was to watch the authors knowledge and opinions grow and change as the writings progressed. I felt as if even though I, as learning about the vast subject of stem cell research and all it entails, the author was also learning right along with me. Her personal progression was just as interesting as the blog itself. The topic is fascinating and could and may potentially affect all of us in one way or another in our lifetime.
The interview was the most impressive of all the aspects of the blog. It gave the blog a personal approach not just a researchers perspective or interested party but a human element.
Emily’s blog was educational, informative and interesting. I wanted to read more when I was finished with her final entry. That is a sure sign of a solid topic and skilled writer. The only errors I found were it was hard to read with the changes to the font. I also found some minor spelling errors but they were minimal considering the length and number of entries in the blog. She clearly feels passionate about this topic and that took over which perhaps lead to the errors. I found that most errors mentioned were corrected, like the consistency of the font, in her newer entries.
Perhaps one suggestion I have for Emily is to give definitions to words or medical terms used immediately in the blog when used, maybe within parenthesis directly following the term or word.
C.Whitaker
Sunday, February 7, 2010
Response: Ardnt Roehlig interview 2. 14
Notes: Ardnt Roehlig interview 2. 14
1. What kind of stem cell therapy did you receive? Bone marrow derived mesenchymal stromal cells (MSC)
2. Who is Dr.Slavin? Which of his quotes helped you reach your decision to receive your treatment? "The secret is to do the treatment of choice in the early stages of the disease before irreversible changes occur,"
http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/
Shimon Slavin, M.D.
Professor of Medicine
Scientific & Medical Director
The International Center for Cell Therapy & Cancer Immunotherapy (CTCI)
Top Ichilov at the Weizman Center,
Tel Aviv Medical Complex
14 Weizman Street
Tel Aviv 64239, ISRAEL
slavin@CTCIcenter.com
3. Are you opposed to human embryonic stem cell (hESC) research? What is your opinion of hESCs? If it helps the patient, absolutely not. If you are sick and it will help you, then you should be able to receive treatment. This is a political question, as soon as the person who is against this needs this kind of help, all of the sudden they are for it and try to find a way to jump the line to be first.
4. Have you noticed a difference in your condition since the last interview? My condition is up and down, but from 100% of the speed of progression prior to infusion, I believe I’m now somewhere at 10-20% of that speed of progression.
5. How long ago did you receive your stem cell therapy in Istanbul? March 6, 2009.
6. You mentioned trying the next generation of Dr.Slavin's treatment, what will this entail? Will you have to go back to Istanbul? What are the differences between the new generation treatment and the treatment you received? When will you be able to receive this treatment? This treatment will target even more cell growth, but is in testing and approval stage with the Israeli government at this time, so not yet available. Istanbul or Athens. It is not known yet, as Dr. Slavin has told me to wait a full year to asses the progression of my disease.
7. Why did you agree to have your story posted on scienceblog.com? If I’m going to be a guinea pig, I might as well share my experience.
8. How has this treatment effected your daily life? I am grateful for it as I still have some ability as compared to where I would have been with out treatment.
9. Is there anything else you would like to add about your personal opinions/experiences regarding stem cell treatments? I think we are on the cusp of finding something successful.
Thursday, February 4, 2010
Excellent research!
Wednesday, February 3, 2010
Response: difference between adult stem cells and hESCs 13
Notes: difference between adult stem cells and hESCs 13
hESCs can be easily cultured, adult stem cells are rare and more limited
hESCs are pluripotent and can become any type of cell, adult stem cells can only be cultured into more of their original tissues
hESCs are easy to culture, adult stem cells are challenging to find in mature tissues
number of cells you can culture through adult stem cells are still limited. This is a challenge because mass amounts of cells are needed for stem cell therapies.
scientists are curious to see if hESCs will be rejected less during transplant than adult stem cells. they will be able to know after clinical trails are more developed since they have only recently been approved the the United State's FDA.
Thursday, January 28, 2010
Response: X Cell Center Website Blog 12
Notes: X Cell Center Website Blog 12
Thursday, January 7, 2010
Response: Stem Cell Therapy Michaela Rodrigues 11
Notes: Stem Cell Therapy Michaela Rodrigues 11
Sunday, January 3, 2010
Response: Stem Cell Therapy Reverses Blindness 10
Notes: Stem Cell Therapy Reverses Blindness 10
Thursday, December 17, 2009
Response: Catholic politician supports hESC research 9
Notes: Catholic politician supports hESC research 9
Friday, December 11, 2009
Response: CNN stem cell video 8
I don't mean to force my opinion, because it's not that strong yet. I'm trying to let this new information settle into my brain.
While my opinion has changed, I was a little shocked that the embryos are 4 - 6 days old when the stem cells are harvested from them. Looking back, I should have realized that stem cells don't just magically appear in an embryo. It has to have time to be fertilized and for everything to grow.
Watching this interview reminded me of Arndt Roehlig. He's the man I interviewed who's living proof of the change that stem cells can make in one person's life. He didn't use hESCs in his therapy, but it's the same idea. His symptoms have been relieved, so far, by 90%. That's amazing. Think of what this could do for someone with Parkinson's disease, or someone who was once told they could never walk again. What a miracle this could be for so many people.
Notes: CNN stem cell video 8
the hESC do come from days old embryos.
it destroys early human life
the breakthrough in stem cell research in the areas of Parkinson's disease and paralysis are due to is the relaxed conditions for stem cell research.
"13 more hESC lines approved from scientific research"
4-6 day old embryos are used to take stem cells from during research.
Dr.Francis Collins is the scientist/representative chosen by Obama, who is being interviewed about stem cell research for the government. He is and Evangelical Christian (a Christian of very deep faith). he believes hESC research is ethical, and the standards are "defensible" He hopes for a revolution in medicine
the stem cells come from embryos that would have otherwise been discarded.
stem cells are collected after 4-6 days of fertalization because in these early steps they can be turned into virtually any type of cell
spinal cord injuries may soon be able to be repaired by hESCs
research isn't moving swiftly, but the research would be faster if there were fewer restrictions on the research of hESCs.
the first human clinical trial was approved earlier this year for hESCs, however it has not enrolled it's first patient
Obama's new policy has made 13 new lines of stem cell research available
ethical concerns: destruction of embryos....
derived from invetro fertilization, but the embryos are donated voluntarily with written consent
hundreds of thousands of embryos are stored, many are discarded.
isn't it more ethical to use the excess embryo's to help someone rather than discarding them?
president bush was the first president to approve multiple lines of stem cell research, 2001
Sunday, November 29, 2009
Second Peer Response
Emily, I really love your topic, I find it very interesting and I believe it is one to keep an eye on! Your sources appear to be very legitimate and each source contains loads of information. Keep an eye on your spelling and grammatical errors, possibly typing each post on some type of program such as word, pages or open office might limit those errors. I wonder if your responses could be a tad longer? Try to proportion your responses and notes in a way that shows complete thinking and truly reflects upon the article. I found the interview intriguing to read and commend you for being able to arrange that interview! As a whole, excellent idea, I see this building into a very resourceful blog.
Monday, November 23, 2009
Response: California Awards Grants for Research Projects in Nonembryonic Stem Cells. 7
Notes: California Awards Grants for Research Projects in Nonembryonic Stem Cells. 7
Thursday, November 19, 2009
Second Peer Blog Response
Your responses are very well done. There were a few typos, but nothing major. (Make sure you spell response correctly!) I like how you came back to questions and points that you made in earlier posts and tied it all together. Everything came together very neatly. Obviously, this is a hard topic because of the vocabulary and the science involved. You seem to be coping with that quite well, but I think it would be beneficial if you explained some of the terms more and really got acquainted with the topic.
As I said, everything is really coming together. You seem very interested in this topic, and because of that the blog is interesting to read. I like how you drew politics in, I think that it would be interesting to expand on that so that you focus equally on the political, scientific and social aspects of stem cell research.
The writing for the interview was hard to read, as the others said, but apart from that the blog was very easy to read. Your layout is reasonably professional, which is nice. I think it would be good to have all of the fonts the same size. There was some variation in the text which was disconcerting. Your citation is beautiful.
Great job.
Second Peer Blog Response
You seem to know where to find strong, detailed and accurate information, yet your notes on this information are varied in quality. In some notes you are very considerate to detail and go into great depth about the topic; it feels as though one had read the article by the end of them. Whilst in other notes you come across as a little uninterested for you lack much detail. Just try to stay with the greater depth. Your responses tend to be a tad inconsistent as well. In some, you simply restate your notes wit some added detail (which should have been in the notes in the first place) while in others you go on only about your opinions on the matter at hand with out backing them up with facts from the notes. Try to combine your opinions with the facts to make your points more clear. As I have already said, you know where to look for your information. Your interview was detailed and thoughtful, and all your other resources are strong as well. Its nice that you make it so obvious what you are learning, if you have an interest in this filed, you are certainly well along the way to understanding it. So far, you have only reviewed several different types of stem cells, but can you compare them? You seem a little conflicted with your opinions on this issue, can you go into more depth about how each type of treatment effects this? Finally, your blog is well organized and easy to read, but a little dull on the edges, perhaps a brighter or fuller background color would make it more appealing. Also, the red text in your interview is challenging to read.
Second Peer Blog Response
Your responces were very well written and contained alot of information and thoughts. They all had a lot of depth and it was clear that much thought was put into them. Some insights that I gained from the responses was your opinion on certain topics, such as hESC's. I think that the responses would be stronger if you put more opinions in them.
It is very clear that your thoughts are developing throughout your blog posting. For example, you took notes on the man who used his own stemcells, and then the next set of notes was an interview. I thought that the interview was a great idea and provided some good information onj the topic. I believe that the author is learing all about stem cell research and stem cell expirements. You should explore more in the field of politics because I'm sure that there is plenty happining to try to changes laws and that sort of thing.
There is definite connections between the articles posted. I think that more background information would be helpful not only to the reader but to the author. You posted that you did not know alot about stem cell research and I think that more background information would help you.
There are no visual aids in any of your posts. The colors are easy to read, except for the red used in the interview. All of the citations are complete.
The titles are all correct and the blog posts are complete. There are not any extra entries in the blog.
Wednesday, November 18, 2009
Stem Cells are not All Equal: Response Ch.1 6
I found Stem Cell Research by Joseph Panno, Ph.D in the school's library. This book provided straight forward information as well as pictures and diagrams that helped me to understand a lot of the terminology in the articles I've been reading.
What I found most interesting was that embryonic stem cells have more plasticity that adult stem cells. This means that the cell can be manipulated without be destroyed. Using this book as my source of background information is going to be very helpful to me in the future.
The articles that I've been choosing to read are becoming more and more dense. What I mean by this is that the articles have a lot of terminology that I don't understand, at all. The book has already cleared up some of the lingering questions and confusion that I have when reading challenging articles.
Stem Cell Research reminds me of a text book for exactly what I'm learning about. This book gives me both history on the subject (where it originated, dates of first discoveries, etc.) as well as definitions and examples of how the definitions relate back to stem cells in real situation.